With advancements in genetic engineering, we can see news of feats such as gene-editing in the works. What are the possible ethical implications that could arise from advancements such as these?
Hello, Thank you for visiting Alphagen 3.0 Forums!
In regards to your question, while Genetic engineering and gene-editing is beneficial in terms of the prevention, therapeutic management, and treatment allowing different novel approaches to diseases, there are many ethical implications and key considerations that arise along with the advancement since this involves germline modifications and invasive procedures that has been subjected to intense debates over the years. Here are some possible ethical implications:
Safety and Unintended Consequences - Gene editing technologies are still in stages of development, and their long-term effects and potential unintended consequences are unknown. Concerns have been raised about the safety and responsible use of these technologies, including the risk of off-target effects, genetic mosaicism, and unanticipated consequences for future generations. The scientific community is cautious about germline editing, and the United States and many other countries have significant policy and regulatory restrictions on using germline human genome editing in people.
Bioethics on Equity and Access - Genetic interventions may create disparities between those who have and do not have access to these technologies. Ethical concerns arise if these advances contribute to the exacerbation of existing social inequalities, such as widening the gap between those who can afford genetic enhancements and those who cannot.
Issues on Autonomy and Human Dignity - Human dignity, autonomy, and the right to personal identity are all called into question by genetic interventions. Modifying the human genome could result in the loss of individuality, the commodification of traits, and new questions about what it means to be human.
It also has implications on Eugenics and Discrimination as the misuse of genetic engineering could lead to discriminatory practices and eugenic ideologies, where certain traits or characteristics are promoted or stigmatized. There are concerns about reinforcing existing biases, discrimination against individuals with natural variations, and creating a society driven by genetic determinism. Lastly, The environment and ecosystems can also be impacted by genetic engineering. The release of genetically modified organisms into the environment may have unanticipated ecological consequences and raise ethical concerns about the potential disruption of natural systems.
There are still many other ethical considerations that are needed to be considered in the advancements of genetic engineering. Here are articles you can read for more information about this matter:
de Miguel Beriain I. (2018). Human dignity and gene editing: Using human dignity as an argument against modifying the human genome and germline is a logical fallacy. EMBO reports, 19(10), e46789. https://doi.org/10.15252/embr.201846789
Hello, Thank you for visiting Alphagen 3.0 Forums!
In regards to your question, while Genetic engineering and gene-editing is beneficial in terms of the prevention, therapeutic management, and treatment allowing different novel approaches to diseases, there are many ethical implications and key considerations that arise along with the advancement since this involves germline modifications and invasive procedures that has been subjected to intense debates over the years. Here are some possible ethical implications:
Safety and Unintended Consequences - Gene editing technologies are still in stages of development, and their long-term effects and potential unintended consequences are unknown. Concerns have been raised about the safety and responsible use of these technologies, including the risk of off-target effects, genetic mosaicism, and unanticipated consequences for future generations. The scientific community is cautious about germline editing, and the United States and many other countries have significant policy and regulatory restrictions on using germline human genome editing in people.
Bioethics on Equity and Access - Genetic interventions may create disparities between those who have and do not have access to these technologies. Ethical concerns arise if these advances contribute to the exacerbation of existing social inequalities, such as widening the gap between those who can afford genetic enhancements and those who cannot.
Issues on Autonomy and Human Dignity - Human dignity, autonomy, and the right to personal identity are all called into question by genetic interventions. Modifying the human genome could result in the loss of individuality, the commodification of traits, and new questions about what it means to be human.
It also has implications on Eugenics and Discrimination as the misuse of genetic engineering could lead to discriminatory practices and eugenic ideologies, where certain traits or characteristics are promoted or stigmatized. There are concerns about reinforcing existing biases, discrimination against individuals with natural variations, and creating a society driven by genetic determinism. Lastly, The environment and ecosystems can also be impacted by genetic engineering. The release of genetically modified organisms into the environment may have unanticipated ecological consequences and raise ethical concerns about the potential disruption of natural systems.
There are still many other ethical considerations that are needed to be considered in the advancements of genetic engineering. Here are articles you can read for more information about this matter:
Perspectives on Gene Editing: Harvard Researchers, others share their views on key issues in the field
de Miguel Beriain I. (2018). Human dignity and gene editing: Using human dignity as an argument against modifying the human genome and germline is a logical fallacy. EMBO reports, 19(10), e46789. https://doi.org/10.15252/embr.201846789
Hope this helps!
- Alphagen 3.0